1/72 Zeroes: A6M5 “Zekes” as Seen in “The Eternal Zero” 「永遠のゼロ」

eien posterAs an American with a deep interest in WW2 history, I am always curious to see representations of the War from “the other side.” The 2013 Japanese feature film The Eternal Zero 「永遠のゼロ」 tells the story of one contemporary Japanese family’s attempt to understand their grandfather’s death as a kamikaze pilot towards the end of the War. As the 20-something brother and sister conduct a series of interviews with aging Japanese veterans who might have known their grandfather, a rather unexpected image comes into view, both through the veterans’ talk and through flashbacks.

When I lived in Japan as a college student in 1986-87, I found that school-age children there seemed to have very little idea about any atrocities committed by Japanese forces in WW2. The notion that Japan was one of the world’s most peaceful nations remained largely undisturbed in their minds. To me, one of the bittersweet ironies about their blissful ignorance is that I don’t actually think they are wrong; Japanese society as those kids and I and many others know it is quite peaceful and orderly and friendly — which makes it all the more important for anyone alive today to understand how exactly such a nation came to commit the war crimes it did in the 1930s and ’40s. The first time I watched The Eternal Zero I wondered what version of that past I would see. Would it look anything like the American version, compliments of Hollywood and wartime messaging, showing fanatical Japanese pilots of all ages dying for the emperor, almost without a second thought? Or would it be a Japanese neo-nationalist revision of the kamikaze, depicting them as noble warriors who made the ultimate personal sacrifice? Or would it be something else?

It turned out to be something else: the film portraysca84e801 the protagonist of the war story, Flight Officer Kyuzo Miyabe, as a highly skilled fighter pilot who assiduously avoids direct combat because he has promised his wife that he will come back to her and their newborn daughter. Contrary to all stereotypes, this Zero pilot really wants to get through the war alive! He builds a reputation as a coward and earns the widespread scorn of his comrades. Because of his skill as a pilot, however, he retains his status and eventually comes to command a “special attack” (特攻 tokkô)¹ training squadron.

Now Miyabe finds himself in an acute moral dilemma. The officer who is so intent on surviving the war has been placed in charge of a cadre of extremely young recruits whose participation in combat will mean certain death for them. What does he do? For one thing, he stalls, rating his trainees as “not yet competent,” no matter how much their skills progress, for as long as he can. When that tactic no longer holds, Miyabe decides that he simply cannot send them to their deaths while he remains alive, and that is when — against all currents in the story up to that point — he resolves to die in a suicide mission. He dies not for the emperor, and far from willingly. And his painful choice is also not driven by any samurai code of honor. He dies because the ethics of the situation as he sees it leave him no choice.

15708-the-eternal-zero-aka-eien-no-0

A6M5 Zeke duo_012As someone who believes that the way histories are told has the power to affect human choices right now, I care whether this movie has “gotten it right” — in my judgment. For instance, I would not want the film to glorify war or the kamikaze strategy, because that might justify the use of violence and coerced suicide around the world today. Does it? I would say not. Although there is a somewhat controversial scene in which the grandson defends the tokkô pilots as something very different from “terrorists,” as a friend calls them, the film portrays the entire history of suicide attacks as a sad and tragic episode in which young men were made to kill themselves whether they liked it or not, and the film makes it quite clear that they did not want to die. Yet I would also not want the film to do such a good job at repainting the Japanese face of the war that we conclude that the Japan of those years “wasn’t that bad.” I don’t think the film falls into that trap either. There are cruel fanatics in the story, and it does look like a bad time to be Japanese.

Ultimately, what the film does is to humanize the Japanese of the war era. They come across as individuals like anyone else embroiled in the moral and social complexities of wartime.  Is that wishful thinking on the part of 21st-century Japanese filmmakers? Surely not. How can we ever really explain the panoply of monstrous actions taken in war — such as the infamous Rape of Nanking, perpetrated by the Japanese army in China, among a multitude of other atrocities committed at one time or another by virtually every nation throughout history — when we know that the vast majority of human beings are basically decent at the personal level, no matter where you find them? The real question is not whether certain countries are “good” and others “bad,” but rather how any country can get its warriors to do questionable, or even monstrous, things. The Eternal Zero offers one possible answer to that timeless, crucial question, and if any modern Japanese viewers were to take the film as license to inch back a bit closer towards aggressive nationalism, I would say that they were missing the point. In fact, this story should give everyone around the world pause when considering extreme nationalism anywhere.

¹In Japanese, the pilots who flew the suicide missions are not referred to as “kamikazes” but rather as tokkô, which is short for 特別攻撃 tokubetsu kôgeki or “special attack” units.


IMG_1696

IMG_1695The “Zeke” models pictured here are actually based on the aircraft in The Eternal Zero. Tamiya came out with a version of the A6M5 with decals to match the fictitious squadron shown in the film. I purchased two of the kits so I could show two planes in a situation similar to that depicted in the movie. I struggled with the question of weathering and paint-chipping… Late-war Japanese aircraft seemed to lose a lot of their paint, but I had never tried recreating that look, and I was afraid I might ruin two perfectly good models if I flubbed it. I also knew that they could look really beautiful as fighter planes if I left them pristine, but in the end I went for it, and these are the results.

I used the “lost salt” method of paint chipping, which involves sprinkling salt onto a

SAMSUNG DIGITAL CAMERA

The Salting

water-misted undercoat of silver, letting the salt get dry and a bit crusty, airbrushing over it with the actual color, and then rubbing the salt crystals away when the paint dries. I think it kinda worked, but you can judge for yourself by the gallery below. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Images to accompany comment #3 below:

 

 

4 responses to “1/72 Zeroes: A6M5 “Zekes” as Seen in “The Eternal Zero” 「永遠のゼロ」

  1. It sounds like an interesting film and a perspective we don’t often hear about. Like many countries who have waged war on others, the people are a mix of those who want to wage war, and those who are forced by fear to wage war. Most people are good inside, it’s what external influences do that turn them into the the monsters many have seen to become. The model looks excellent and the salting has worked well I’d say.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Many thanks to Chules at http://www.ww2in172.com for the following enlightening comment on this post. I have added the images he references to the end of the post.

    Dear Chris,

    Your review of The Eternal Zero was interesting, thought-provoking, and insightful. Your posts always send me on a quest for more information and I immediately ordered the movie. I admire your approach to writing about these difficult subjects and the way you’re able to thread the needle between informing your readers — forcing them to think about these difficult topics — and glorifying war. You invariably succeed.

    I haven’t yet seen the movie but the 721 Naval Air Group was not fictitious. Please see the attached photos that I gathered quickly from a couple of my books. I have attached a scan of the 721 Jinrai Butai (Thunder of the Gods) from Eduardo Cea’s Tokubetsu Kogeki Tai (Air Collection No. 8) p.40, as well as a scan of a photo from Hata et al’s Japanese Naval Aces and Fighter Units p.227 of 721 pilots ceremonially drinking their last sake (actually water) just before take-off. I’ve also included a scan from Famous Airplanes No. 56 p.5 of a profile of 721-23.

    I loved your excellent diorama and I think the lost salt weathering technique worked very well. Some of your readers who, like me, don’t have the skill to build a good model may want to know that Doyusha put out a plastic prebuilt of the 721-68 (Zero Fighter #3). Also Witty Wings put out a diecast model of 721-23 (72-001-004). I have attached a scan of the Doyusha.

    Congratulations on your awesome post and please keep them coming.

    Best regards,
    chules

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s